The holidays are approaching.
Which means food.
Travel.
Family gatherings.
Friends you haven’t seen in a while.
Possibly explaining your life choices to a relative you speak to twice a year.
And compliments.
“You look great!”
“I’m so proud of you.”
“You’re such a good parent.”
“You did an amazing job with this.”
“You seem really happy.”
For some people, receiving a compliment is lovely. For others, it creates an immediate and overwhelming desire to exit through the nearest wall.
Someone says: “I love your outfit!”
And suddenly you’re explaining: “Oh, this? I’ve had it forever. It was on sale. It actually doesn’t fit that well. I almost didn’t wear it.”
Okay.
They said they liked your sweater.
You have somehow responded with a full financial disclosure and three reasons they were incorrect.
Or someone says: “You’re really good at what you do.”
And you immediately say: “Oh God, no. I have no idea what I’m doing.”
Maybe you laugh.
Deflect.
Change the subject.
Return the compliment immediately.
Explain why the accomplishment wasn’t actually impressive.
Or simply stand there thinking: Please stop looking at me.
If compliments are supposed to feel good, why can receiving one feel so deeply uncomfortable?
Compliments Put Attention Directly on You
Let’s start with the obvious.
A compliment means somebody has noticed you.
For some people: Wonderful.
For others: Absolutely not. Please return your attention to literally anything else.
If you’re uncomfortable being perceived, evaluated, or made the center of attention, even positive attention can activate self-consciousness.
Someone compliments your presentation.
Now you’re thinking about how you presented.
Someone compliments your appearance.
Now you’re thinking about how you look.
Someone tells you you’re funny.
Now you’re suddenly aware of every joke you have ever attempted.
The compliment may be positive.
But the attention itself can still feel vulnerable.
Research on social anxiety suggests that heightened self-focused attention can contribute to increased awareness of one’s behavior, physical sensations, and perceived appearance to others (Spurr & Stopa, 2002).
So a compliment can suddenly turn the spotlight inward.
How do I respond?
What is my face doing?
Did I say thank you weird?
Do they expect me to say something else?
Am I being arrogant if I agree?
You have now turned receiving a compliment into a job interview.
Sometimes the Compliment Doesn’t Match How You See Yourself
Imagine someone tells you: “You’re so confident.”
But internally, you feel insecure all the time.
Or: “You’re incredibly successful.”
Meanwhile, your brain has a detailed spreadsheet containing every goal you haven’t reached yet.
Or: “You’re such a good person.”
And your brain immediately retrieves a mistake from eleven years ago.
When positive feedback conflicts with how we already see ourselves, we may have difficulty integrating it.
Research on self-verification suggests that people are often motivated to maintain consistent views of themselves—even when those views aren’t particularly positive (Swann, 2012).
Familiar information can feel more believable.
So if your internal belief is: I’m not good enough, and someone says: “You’re amazing,” your brain may not respond: Wonderful. Updating self-concept.
It may respond:
- Incorrect.
- They don’t really know me.
- They’re just being nice.
- They say that to everyone.
- If they knew the real me, they wouldn’t think that.
Your brain has received new evidence and immediately filed a motion to have it excluded.
The Compliment Rejection Department
There are many ways to reject a compliment without technically rejecting it.
- Minimizing: “It wasn’t a big deal.”
- Explaining: “I only got the promotion because someone else left.”
- Discounting: “Anyone could’ve done it.”
- Redirecting: “Well, YOU look amazing!”
- Discrediting the source: “She’s just being nice.”
- Introducing contrary evidence: “Yeah, but I messed up this other part.”
- Making sure nobody thinks you’re too pleased with yourself: “Trust me, I’m really not that good.”
At some point, someone has handed you a compliment and you’ve returned it with edits.
Why Is “Thank You” So Hard?
Try this experiment.
Imagine someone says: “You did a really good job.”
And you respond: “Thank you. I’m proud of how it turned out.”
How does that feel?
For some people: Perfectly normal.
For others: Oh absolutely not.
Because now it feels like you’re agreeing with the compliment. And agreeing might feel arrogant. Self-centered. Full of yourself. Like you think you’re better than everyone.
Some people learned very early that humility means minimizing yourself.
- Don’t brag.
- Don’t show off.
- Don’t think too highly of yourself.
- Stay humble.
Those messages aren’t necessarily harmful on their own. Humility can be a wonderful quality. But sometimes we accidentally learn: If someone says something positive about me, I need to immediately demonstrate that I don’t believe it too much.
So: “You’re really talented.” becomes: “No, no, no, I’m really not.” Just in case the Humility Police are nearby.
The Holidays Can Make This Extra Complicated
This time of year can be particularly interesting if receiving attention already makes you uncomfortable.
Maybe you’re seeing people you haven’t seen since last Thanksgiving. And suddenly:
- “You look different!”
- “You look great!”
- “You lost weight!”
- “You look so healthy!”
- “I heard about your new job!”
- “Your mom told me what you’ve been doing!”
Even well-intentioned comments can bring attention to parts of ourselves we’d rather not discuss.
Appearance-based compliments can be especially complicated. Someone might have a history of body-image concerns. Their body may have changed because of stress, grief, illness, medication, recovery, or something deeply personal. Or maybe they simply don’t want their body to become the Thanksgiving table’s community discussion topic.
A compliment can be well-intentioned and uncomfortable. Both can be true. You don’t have to force yourself to enjoy every positive comment someone makes about you.
Compliments Can Also Create Pressure
Sometimes the uncomfortable part isn’t the compliment itself. It’s what your brain thinks comes next.
“You’re always so organized.”
Brain: Great. Now I have to remain organized forever.
“You’re such a good employee.”
Excellent. I can never have an off day.
“You’re so strong.”
Cool. I guess I’m not allowed to fall apart.
“You’re the one who always has everything together.”
Wonderful. No pressure.
Positive labels can become standards we feel responsible for maintaining. Especially if your self-worth is heavily tied to performance, achievement, or other people’s approval.
Research on contingent self-worth suggests that when self-esteem depends heavily on success or approval in particular areas, events in those domains can have stronger effects on how we evaluate ourselves (Crocker & Wolfe, 2001).
So sometimes a compliment doesn’t register as: “Someone appreciates this about me.” It registers as: “New expectation unlocked.”
Compliments Can Feel Like Something You Now Have to Repay
This is especially true if you’re used to monitoring other people’s needs.
Someone says: “You look beautiful.”
Immediate response: “YOU LOOK BEAUTIFUL TOO.”
Maybe you genuinely think they are.
But notice the speed.
Did you actually receive the compliment?
Or did you immediately throw one back because holding positive attention for three consecutive seconds felt unbearable?
Sometimes compliments create a strange sense of social debt.
They said something nice.
Now I need to say something nice.
They made me feel good.
Now I need to make them feel good.
But a compliment isn’t an invoice. You are allowed to receive something kind without immediately paying it back.
Sometimes You Don’t Trust the Compliment
Maybe compliments haven’t always been safe.
Maybe praise came before someone wanted something.
Maybe compliments were manipulative.
Maybe approval was inconsistent.
Maybe people praised you publicly and criticized you privately.
Maybe affection depended on performance.
Maybe someone complimenting your appearance meant they were about to comment on your weight.
Maybe praise felt less like appreciation and more like evaluation.
If that’s part of your history, your brain may hear: “You’re amazing.” and respond: What’s the catch?
That reaction makes sense. Our brains use previous experiences to predict what current interactions mean.
But sometimes the current compliment really is just…a compliment.
No hidden contract.
No performance review.
No follow-up question.
No timeshare presentation.
Someone noticed something they appreciate about you.
Notice What You Do With Positive Evidence
This is where compliments become interesting therapeutically.
Let’s say your belief is: I’m incompetent.
Then you make a mistake.
Your brain: SEE?
Evidence accepted immediately.
Someone praises your work.
Your brain: They were being nice.
Evidence rejected.
You receive positive feedback from three people. They don’t know the whole story.
You succeed at something difficult. I got lucky.
You work incredibly hard. Anyone could’ve done it.
You make one mistake. Finally. Reliable data.
If negative evidence automatically counts and positive evidence automatically doesn’t, your self-concept isn’t being built from a fair sample.
The jury has received very specific instructions.
Try Not Arguing With the Compliment
You don’t have to believe the compliment completely.
You don’t have to stare into the mirror afterward and announce: I AM INCREDIBLE.
We’re starting smaller.
Try simply not rejecting it.
Someone says: “You look great.”
Try: “Thank you.”
Then stop.
I know.
Terrifying.
Someone says:
“You handled that really well.”
“Thank you. That means a lot.”
Stop.
Someone says:
“I’m proud of you.”
“Thank you.”
You don’t need to provide evidence against yourself.
You don’t need to explain why the accomplishment wasn’t impressive.
You don’t need to tell them about the six things you did poorly.
You don’t need to immediately compliment them back.
Just let the sentence exist.
Try the Compliment Experiment
The next time someone compliments you, notice your first urge.
Do you want to:
- Deflect?
- Minimize?
- Make a joke?
- Explain?
- Return the compliment?
- Disagree?
- Change the subject?
Then try this:
Step 1: Say thank you.
That’s the whole first step.
Step 2: Don’t add a disclaimer.
No: “Thank you, but…”
We are temporarily banning the word but from compliment reception.
Step 3: Notice the discomfort.
Maybe you feel exposed.
Embarrassed.
Skeptical.
Proud.
Awkward.
Warm.
Anxious.
You don’t have to fix the feeling.
Step 4: Let the compliment remain unresolved.
You don’t have to decide whether it’s objectively true.
Someone thinks something positive about you.
Can that simply be information?
“They experienced me that way.”
That’s enough.
You Don’t Have to Turn a Compliment Into an Affirmation
This distinction can help if positive self-talk feels fake.
If someone tells you: “You’re an amazing friend,” you don’t have to immediately adopt: I AM AN AMAZING FRIEND AND EVERYONE LOVES ME.
Your brain may respond: Absolutely not.
Instead: “My friend experiences me as someone who matters to them.”
Someone says: “You’re really talented.”
Try: “They see something in my work that they value.”
Someone says: “You look great.”
Try: “They wanted to say something kind about how I look.”
You don’t have to transform the compliment into a universal truth. Just resist immediately transforming it into a lie.
And About Those Holiday Appearance Comments…
If you’re heading into Thanksgiving or other holiday gatherings and you don’t want comments about your body, you’re allowed to redirect them. Even compliments.
You can say: “Thanks. I’m actually trying not to focus much on my weight these days.”
Or: “I appreciate that. I’d rather not talk about my body, though.”
Or simply change the subject.
Receiving compliments more openly does not mean you’re obligated to accept commentary about every part of yourself. Boundaries still apply. Someone’s positive intention doesn’t require you to enjoy the impact.
Maybe Practice This Holiday Season
If someone says something kind about you over the holidays, see what happens if you don’t immediately swat it away.
Maybe Grandma says: “I’m really proud of everything you’re doing.”
You don’t need to explain what you haven’t accomplished yet.
Maybe someone tells you dinner was delicious.
You don’t have to provide a detailed review of everything that went wrong while cooking it.
Maybe a friend tells you they love your outfit.
No need to produce the receipt.
Maybe someone tells you you’ve helped them.
You don’t need to remind them of all the times you weren’t helpful.
Try: “Thank you.”
Maybe: “That means a lot to me.”
And then tolerate the deeply unsettling experience of someone thinking something nice about you.
You Are Allowed to Be Seen Positively
Compliments can be uncomfortable for a lot of reasons.
They put attention on us.
They may conflict with how we see ourselves.
They may create pressure.
They may activate old experiences with approval, performance, or evaluation.
They may simply make us feel vulnerable.
You don’t have to suddenly love them. But maybe you can become a little more curious about what happens when someone offers you positive information about yourself. Especially if your brain is already very comfortable collecting the negative information.
You don’t have to agree with every compliment.
You don’t have to make it part of your identity.
You don’t even have to feel good when you hear it.
Maybe the practice is simply: Don’t throw it away immediately.
Let someone appreciate you.
Let someone notice something good.
Let someone be proud of you.
Let their perception exist alongside your own.
And this Thanksgiving, if someone tells you: “You did an amazing job with dinner.”
Perhaps resist the urge to respond: “Well, the potatoes are a little dry.”
We know.
You have notes.
Your brain always has notes.
Just say thank you.
References
Crocker, J., & Park, L. E. (2004). The costly pursuit of self-esteem. Psychological Bulletin, 130(3), 392–414. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.130.3.392
Crocker, J., & Wolfe, C. T. (2001). Contingencies of self-worth. Psychological Review, 108(3), 593–623. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.108.3.593
Kille, D. R., Eibach, R. P., Wood, J. V., & Holmes, J. G. (2017). Who can’t take a compliment? The role of construal level and self-esteem in accepting positive feedback from close others. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 68, 40–49. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2016.05.003
Spurr, J. M., & Stopa, L. (2002). Self-focused attention in social phobia and social anxiety. Clinical Psychology Review, 22(7), 947–975. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0272-7358(02)00107-1
Swann, W. B., Jr. (2012). Self-verification theory. In P. A. M. Van Lange, A. W. Kruglanski, & E. T. Higgins (Eds.), Handbook of theories of social psychology (Vol. 2, pp. 23–42). SAGE Publications. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781446249222.n27

Leave a Reply