“I Should Be Over This By Now” — According to Whom?

There is a particular kind of frustration that happens when you’re not only hurting, but also annoyed with yourself for still hurting.

Maybe something happened six months ago.

Or two years ago.

Or ten.

Maybe a relationship ended.

Someone died.

You went through something traumatic.

Your family hurt you.

You made a mistake you deeply regret.

Your body changed.

You lost a version of your life you thought you were going to have.

And at some point, another thought joins the original pain: “I should be over this by now.”

Ah, yes.

The completely legitimate and universally recognized Emotional Recovery Deadline™.

Apparently yours has passed.

Unfortunately, nobody remembered to send you the paperwork.

According to Whom?

Whenever you notice the word should, it’s worth getting curious.

Not because every “should” is bad.

I should probably pay my taxes.

I should generally stop at red lights.

Some shoulds are useful. But others are rules we’ve absorbed without ever asking where they came from.

So if you’re thinking: “I should be over this by now.”

Try finishing the sentence with: According to whom?

Who decided how long this was supposed to take?

Was it you?

Your family?

A partner?

Friends?

Someone who said, “You’re still upset about that?”

A culture that gets increasingly uncomfortable when grief lasts longer than the sympathy cards?

Or are you comparing yourself to some imaginary emotionally healthy person who apparently experiences difficult things, processes them efficiently, learns an important lesson, drinks some water, and moves on by Thursday?

Because I have some disappointing news about that person.

I don’t think they exist.

Time Passing and Something Being Healed Are Not the Same Thing

We often talk about emotional healing as though it should follow a predictable timeline.

Something happens.

It hurts.

You process it.

Time passes.

You heal.

Done.

But humans are inconveniently more complicated than that.

Research on grief, for example, shows that people do not move through one universal sequence of predictable stages. People adapt to loss in different ways and along different trajectories (Szuhany et al., 2021).

Trauma recovery isn’t identical from person to person either.

Neither is recovering from a breakup.

Or betrayal.

Or childhood experiences.

Or shame.

Or the loss of a future you thought you were going to have.

Time matters. But time passing is not the same thing as your brain and body having everything they needed to process what happened.

Sometimes ten years have passed, but for eight of those years you were surviving.

Sometimes you didn’t have safety.

Sometimes you didn’t have support.

Sometimes you didn’t understand what happened yet.

Sometimes you were minimizing it.

Sometimes you were taking care of everyone else.

Sometimes you weren’t ready to look at it.

Sometimes you genuinely thought you were fine until something in your life changed and suddenly an old wound became very loud again.

The calendar can tell you how long ago something happened. It cannot tell you how you should feel about it today.

“But It Was So Long Ago.”

Yes.

And?

Something happening a long time ago does not automatically make it emotionally irrelevant. Your brain does not organize experiences according to: Recent → Valid to Be Upset About

Old → Please Delete

Sometimes old experiences become meaningful in new ways as we grow.

You may understand something at 35 that you couldn’t understand at 15.

You may become a parent and suddenly view your own childhood differently.

You may enter a healthy relationship and realize how unhealthy a previous one actually was.

You may finally feel safe enough for emotions you couldn’t afford to feel before to show up.

You may learn language like emotional abuse, trauma, neglect, discrimination, or coercive control and realize: Oh. There was a name for that.

Sometimes healing doesn’t begin when the event ends. Sometimes it begins when you finally understand what happened.

Healing Isn’t the Same Thing as Forgetting

Another problem with “I should be over this” is that we rarely define what over it actually means.

Does it mean:

  • I never think about it?
  • I don’t feel sad anymore?
  • I can talk about it without crying?
  • I forgive everyone involved?
  • It doesn’t affect any of my relationships?
  • I never get triggered?
  • I don’t wish things had been different?

Because those are very different expectations.

You can heal from something and still wish it hadn’t happened.

You can accept a loss and still miss someone.

You can process trauma and still have moments when your body remembers.

You can leave an unhealthy relationship and occasionally grieve the good parts.

You can forgive yourself and still regret something.

You can build an entirely new life and still feel sad about the life you didn’t get.

Healing doesn’t necessarily mean: “This no longer affects me.”

Sometimes it means: “This affects me differently now.”

That’s a much more realistic standard.

Pain Doesn’t Reset Your Progress

This is one of the sneakiest parts.

You can feel like you’ve made enormous progress.

Then something happens.

A date on the calendar.

A smell.

A song.

A conversation.

Seeing someone’s social media post.

A holiday.

Becoming the age someone was when something happened.

Watching someone else experience something you didn’t get to have.

And suddenly there it is again.

Sadness.

Anger.

Fear.

Grief.

And your brain immediately announces: “Great. Apparently we have made ZERO progress.”

That’s not how this works.

Feeling something again doesn’t mean you’re back at the beginning.

Imagine walking up a spiral staircase.

You may eventually find yourself facing the same direction again.

It can look familiar.

But you’re not standing on the same step.

You have more information now.

More experiences.

Maybe more coping skills.

More choices.

More understanding.

You can revisit the same pain from a different place. Returning to a feeling is not the same thing as returning to square one.

Sometimes “I Should Be Over This” Is Actually Shame

There may be something underneath the frustration. Because “I should be over this by now” often isn’t really about time. It can mean:

  • I shouldn’t be this sensitive.
  • Other people have been through worse.
  • A stronger person wouldn’t still be affected by this.
  • There must be something wrong with me.
  • I’m embarrassed that this still matters.
  • I don’t want anyone to know I’m still struggling.

Now we’re not talking about healing anymore. We’re talking about judgment. And judgment has a funny habit of showing up when we’re already struggling and offering absolutely nothing useful.

You’re grieving? Have some shame.

You’re anxious? Let’s add self-criticism.

You’re having a trauma response? Excellent. Perhaps you’d also like to feel defective about it.

Very efficient system.

Unfortunately, research consistently connects harsh self-criticism with psychological distress, while interventions designed to cultivate self-compassion can reduce self-criticism (Vidal & Soldevilla, 2023; Wakelin et al., 2022). Which means bullying yourself about the fact that you’re hurting is probably not the revolutionary healing strategy your brain thinks it is.

Acceptance Is Not the Same Thing as Approval

Sometimes people resist accepting that something still hurts because acceptance feels like giving up.

“If I accept that I’m still affected by this, doesn’t that mean I’m choosing to stay stuck?”

No.

Acceptance is information.

This is where I am right now.

That’s different from:

This is where I will always be.

You can acknowledge:

  • “This still hurts.”
  • “This still affects me.”
  • “I’m still angry.”
  • “I still miss them.”
  • “I haven’t fully made peace with this.”

without deciding that nothing can ever change.

In fact, it’s difficult to work effectively with an experience while simultaneously insisting you aren’t supposed to be having it.

There Is a Difference Between Giving Yourself Time and Staying Stuck

Now for an important distinction.

Saying there isn’t a universal timeline for healing does not mean that time alone will fix everything.

Sometimes pain remains intense because something is keeping it going.

Avoidance.

Rumination.

Isolation.

Self-blame.

Unprocessed trauma.

Repeated reassurance seeking.

Ongoing contact with someone who continues hurting you.

Substance use.

Trying desperately not to think about what happened.

A belief you haven’t been able to examine.

Or simply not having had the support or treatment you needed.

There are also mental health conditions in which symptoms persist and significantly interfere with someone’s life, including PTSD and prolonged grief disorder.

So the alternative to: “I should be over this.” isn’t necessarily: “I guess I’ll feel this way forever.”

There is another option: “I’m still struggling with this. Maybe I deserve support with it.”

That is a very different conversation.

Try Replacing the Deadline With Curiosity

Instead of asking: “Why am I not over this yet?”

Try: “What still hurts about this?”

Instead of: “What’s wrong with me?”

Try: “What happens inside me when I’m reminded of it?”

Instead of: “Why can’t I let this go?”

Try: “What am I afraid would happen if I did?”

Instead of:“Why does this still matter?”

Try:“What did this experience mean to me?”

Instead of:“How much longer is this going to take?”

Try:“What do I need now that I didn’t have then?”

Those questions give us somewhere to go. Shame usually doesn’t.

The “According to Whom?” Exercise

The next time you catch yourself thinking: “I should be over this by now,” stop and ask:

1. According to whom?

Where did I learn that this amount of time should have been enough?

2. What do I think “over it” should look like?

Am I expecting myself to never think about it, never feel anything, never get triggered, or never wish things had been different?

3. What has actually changed?

  • Maybe you still get sad, but less often.
  • Maybe you recover more quickly.
  • Maybe you understand yourself better.
  • Maybe you set boundaries now.
  • Maybe you don’t blame yourself anymore.
  • Maybe the memory still hurts, but it no longer controls every decision.

Progress is easy to miss when the only outcome you’re measuring is “Does this hurt at all?”

4. What still needs attention?

  • Is there grief you haven’t allowed yourself to feel?
  • Something you’re avoiding?
  • A belief you’re carrying?
  • A conversation you need to have?
  • A boundary?
  • A trauma response?
  • Something you may want professional support working through?

5. What would I say to someone I cared about?

If someone you loved had lived through exactly what you did and said: “I can’t believe I’m still affected by this.”

Would you respond: “Yeah, this is getting embarrassing. Wrap it up.”

Probably not.

Maybe you deserve something better than that response too.

Maybe the Goal Isn’t “Getting Over It”

There are experiences we don’t exactly get over. We integrate them. They become part of our history without remaining the entirety of our present.

The grief changes.

The memory changes.

Our understanding changes.

We change.

And sometimes something still aches.

That doesn’t erase the healing that happened around it.

You do not have to measure recovery by how successfully you can pretend something never mattered.

Maybe the better questions are:

  • Does this have the same power over me that it once did?
  • Can I make choices even when the feeling shows up?
  • Am I treating myself differently?
  • Do I understand what happened more clearly?
  • Am I building a life beyond it?

Those are signs of healing too.

So, When Should You Be Over It?

I don’t know.

And neither does the imaginary committee in your head.

There isn’t one deadline that applies to grief, trauma, heartbreak, family wounds, shame, or the countless other things human beings have to learn to carry.

That doesn’t mean you’re powerless.

It doesn’t mean things can’t improve.

And it doesn’t mean every painful pattern should simply be accepted indefinitely.

It means we can stop confusing self-criticism with progress.

Maybe you’ve been carrying this longer than you wish you had.

Maybe you’re tired of it.

Maybe you’re ready for something to change.

All of that can be true.

But before you decide you’re failing because you’re “still” affected by something, ask one more question: According to whom?

The calendar can tell you how much time has passed. It doesn’t get to grade you on how well you’ve healed.

References

Szuhany, K. L., Malgaroli, M., Miron, C. D., & Simon, N. M. (2021). Prolonged grief disorder: Course, diagnosis, assessment, and treatment. Focus, 19(2), 161–172. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.focus.20200052

Vidal, J., & Soldevilla, J. M. (2023). Effect of compassion-focused therapy on self-criticism and self-soothing: A meta-analysis. British Journal of Clinical Psychology, 62(1), 70–81. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjc.12394

Wakelin, K. E., Perman, G., & Simonds, L. M. (2022). Effectiveness of self-compassion-related interventions for reducing self-criticism: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy, 29(1), 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1002/cpp.2586

Werner, A. M., Tibubos, A. N., Rohrmann, S., & Reiss, N. (2019). The clinical trait self-criticism and its relation to psychopathology: A systematic review—Update. Journal of Affective Disorders, 246, 530–547. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2018.12.069


Discover more from Grounded Growth Counseling & Consulting, LLC

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply